“T1 Sparks Controversy: Rookie Benched as CEO Overrules Coaches Before LCK 2025 Kickoff!”
The 2025 LCK season hasn’t even started, and T1 is already making headlines—but for all the wrong reasons. The organization has found itself at the center of a heated controversy after CEO Joe Marsh overruled the coaching staff’s decision to start rookie talent Sin ‘Smash’ Geum-jae over veteran player Lee ‘Gumayusi’ Min-hyung. The unexpected reversal has sparked an intense debate among League of Legends fans, with many questioning the fairness of the move.
T1’s Decision Sparks Outrage
Initially, fans were thrilled to see Gumayusi return to the starting lineup. However, excitement quickly turned to frustration as many began voicing concerns over Smash’s treatment. The rookie had already earned his place on the roster after impressing during the LCK Spring Split, yet he was suddenly relegated to a backup role before the season even began.
“Gumayusi himself debuted and replaced Teddy in the same way Smash is doing with him,” one fan noted on X (formerly Twitter). “Esports is about competition, and when rookies prove their skills, they deserve their shot.”
Many fans were also frustrated with Joe Marsh’s involvement, arguing that a CEO interfering with roster decisions sets a dangerous precedent. “Mass bullying mentality, having the CEO interfere against the coaching staff… seriously disappointing to see,” another user wrote.
A Rookie’s Dream Cut Short?
Smash’s rapid rise through the ranks of the T1 Academy system made him one of the most exciting prospects in Korean League of Legends. He had only recently secured his starting role in January 2025, and his removal so soon has left many questioning whether T1 is mishandling its young talent.
Some fans even compared the situation to Faker’s temporary benching in favor of Lee ‘Clozer’ Ju-hyeon, reminding everyone that esports is ruthlessly competitive. “Faker was benched by rookie Clozer even after winning three World Championships and multiple LCK titles,” one fan pointed out. “Competition is cruel, and this isn’t new.”
Despite the backlash, Marsh attempted to calm the storm, stating that Smash will still be included in scrims and have opportunities to develop. However, this did little to ease the frustration of those who believe the young star deserved a proper shot on the big stage.
What’s Next for T1?
With T1’s season opener set for April 4th against DRX, all eyes will be on the team’s performance. Will the return of Gumayusi prove to be the right call, or will the decision come back to haunt them?
Regardless of the outcome, this controversy highlights a larger issue in esports—the delicate balance between veteran loyalty and nurturing new talent. As the debate rages on, one thing is certain: T1’s 2025 LCK season is already off to a dramatic start.
Fans can catch all the action live on the official LCK YouTube and Twitch channels when the matches begin.
What do you think?
Was T1 right to bring back Gumayusi, or should Smash have kept his spot? Join the conversation online and let us know your thoughts!
